Approved Today. Who Pays 30 Years From Now?

Maybe the more important policy question is whether funding should begin at the start of the infrastructure’s life, rather than only when major repairs are looming.

Share
Approved Today. Who Pays 30 Years From Now?
Photo by Jon Tyson / Unsplash

When a new subdivision is approved, almost everyone involved is looking forward. The developer is thinking about permits, construction and sales. The city or county is thinking about roads, drainage, utilities, density and whether the project meets code. Engineers are designing systems. Attorneys are drafting documents. Buyers are thinking about floor plans, yards and mortgage payments.

Very few people are thinking about the homeowners who may still be there 25 or 30 years later when the private road needs reconstruction, the detention pond needs major work, the drainage system starts failing, or a wastewater system reaches the end of its useful life.

But somebody should be.

Private infrastructure is common in planned communities. Local governments routinely approve developments where homeowners associations are responsible for things like private roads, stormwater facilities, drainage systems and other common assets. San Diego County, for example, tells HOAs that they may be responsible for structural stormwater facilities ranging from shared private roads to detention basins and storm-drain systems. Contra Costa County’s stormwater program even provides model agreements making the HOA responsible for operating and maintaining subdivision stormwater facilities. That answers who maintains the infrastructure. It does not necessarily tell us who will be able to afford replacing it decades later.

The obligation is created long before the bill arrives

A private road can look perfectly fine when the first homes are sold. A detention pond may require little more than routine maintenance for years. Drainage pipes disappear underground and may not attract much attention until something goes wrong.

That is exactly why the future cost is easy to overlook. The decision assigning responsibility is made when the development is approved. The expensive consequences may arrive long after the developer has left, the original planners and engineers have moved on, and the local officials who approved the project are no longer in office. What remains is the HOA. And the homeowners.

Local governments are often quite careful about documenting maintenance responsibility. San Diego County says developments with structural stormwater systems generally have recorded maintenance agreements identifying who is responsible for inspections and upkeep. Henderson County, North Carolina, requires HOA stormwater agreements to say that the association will continuously operate and maintain the facilities and gives the county authority to step in, make repairs and recover the cost from the association if necessary. But maintenance and replacement are not the same thing.

Cleaning a catch basin is maintenance. Replacing a failing drainage system is capital work.

Patching a private road is maintenance. Reconstructing it may be a six- or seven-figure project.

The documents can be very clear about who owns the obligation while saying much less about whether the community inheriting it will have the money when the large bill arrives.

The future homeowner is not in the room

This may be the strangest part of the arrangement. At the moment the responsibility is created, almost everyone at the table has professional expertise: planners, engineers, developers, attorneys, consultants and government reviewers. The future HOA board does not exist yet. Most of the future homeowners are not there either. Yet those future volunteers may eventually be responsible for infrastructure worth hundreds of thousands or millions of dollars.

Some governments are beginning to recognize that simply assigning responsibility is not enough. Anne Arundel County, Maryland, said in 2025 that feedback from HOAs showed governing documents sometimes failed to explain infrastructure obligations clearly enough, creating problems with costs and budgets. Greenville County, South Carolina, goes a step further. Its model HOA stormwater agreement requires a small escrow account for each facility and annual contributions from HOA dues or owner payments toward future maintenance. The important policy point is that funding begins at the start of the infrastructure’s life, not only when major repairs are looming.

That points toward a larger question. Why wait until decades later for a volunteer board to discover what replacement will cost?

For major privately owned infrastructure, development approval could include some combination of expected useful lives, major replacement-cost estimates, long-term funding assumptions, clearer disclosures to buyers, initial turnover funding, and periodic reserve planning after homeowner control begins. That does not guarantee that every future board will fund reserves perfectly. It does mean the community would begin with something more substantial than an obligation and a promise to figure out the money later.

When private infrastructure becomes a public problem

There is another question that is easier to miss. What happens if the private system fails? With wastewater or septic systems, the answer can become obvious quickly because failing systems can create public-health problems.

Stormwater is similar. The pond may sit on HOA property, but water does not necessarily respect subdivision boundaries. That is one reason some local governments reserve the right to enter, repair neglected private stormwater facilities, and charge the responsible owners for the work.

Roads create a different problem. A private road may legally remain the responsibility of the adjoining owners or HOA, but over time it also becomes part of the physical fabric of the community around it. If it deteriorates badly, the consequences can reach beyond pavement condition: emergency access, drainage, pedestrian movement, neighborhood connectivity and the relationship between that road and the surrounding public street network.

Some cities have procedures for converting private streets to public ones. Park City, Utah, for example, allows an HOA to request evaluation when an existing private street has begun functioning as a public roadway, including when it connects to new development or serves public facilities. But the road still must be evaluated against city standards before acceptance.

That raises an awkward long-term possibility. A city can approve private roads relatively early in the life of a development. Decades later, bringing those roads into the public system may require upgrades to newer standards, substantial homeowner expense, high levels of owner agreement and discretionary government approval. The path to public ownership may technically exist while being nearly impossible to use.

The result can be islands of privately maintained infrastructure inside an otherwise public network—some well funded and well maintained, others deteriorating because a relatively small group of homeowners cannot agree on or afford the necessary work. At that point, the question is no longer entirely private.

Maybe the harder question belongs at the beginning

Private infrastructure can work well. Plenty of communities have maintained roads, stormwater systems and other facilities successfully for decades. But putting those systems in private hands changes where the long-term risk lands.

A city or county has professional staff, engineers, taxing authority and access to grants and public financing. A small homeowners association may have a few dozen households and a volunteer board. That does not mean the association cannot manage substantial infrastructure. It does mean the scale and complexity of what it is being asked to inherit should be part of the conversation when the development is approved.

That conversation should include more than who will mow around the pond or patch the road. Someone should be looking at what these systems are likely to cost over their full lives, whether the future community can realistically carry those costs, and what happens if it cannot. There should also be some thought given to whether private infrastructure can ever become part of the public system later, rather than assuming that the arrangement made at subdivision approval will necessarily make sense forever.

Most of those questions are much easier to deal with before the homes are sold than 30 years later. By then, the developer may be gone. The people who approved the project may be gone. The infrastructure is older, current public standards may have changed, and the homeowners may discover that the route from private to public ownership exists mostly on paper. That is how a decision that looked perfectly workable at the beginning can become somebody else’s problem decades later. The infrastructure was approved, the responsibility assigned, and the homes sold. The replacement bill was simply waiting for its turn.

♓︎