HOA Rules That Sound Made Up But Aren’t

... there are rules you could read aloud at dinner and reasonably expect someone to say, “You made that up.” We didn’t.

Share
HOA Rules That Sound Made Up But Aren’t
Photo by Claudio Schwarz / Unsplash

There are HOA rules that sound perfectly ordinary. And then there are rules you could read aloud at dinner and reasonably expect someone to say, “You made that up.” We didn’t.

Here are ten rules that have actually appeared in HOA governing documents or disputes.

#1. Close the garage door
Not eventually. Not when you leave for work. Some HOA rules say garage doors must remain closed whenever the garage is not actively being used. One Arizona community says exactly that: “All garage doors must remain closed when garages are not in use.” Apparently the neighborhood is entitled to see your house. Just not what is inside the garage.

#2. Your curtains may need to be the right color
Yes, the curtains inside your house. One association’s rules require window coverings visible from outside to be beige, white, off-white, or otherwise approved by the board. Interior decorating, now with an exterior review committee.

#3. Christmas has a deadline
Some communities specify exactly when holiday decorations have to come down.
At one California association, the deadline was January 15. Another set of HOA rules gives residents just ten days after most holidays. On January 16, apparently, the wreath becomes a compliance issue.

#4. You may need permission to paint your house the same color
Changing from beige to purple? Maybe architectural review makes sense. Painting beige over the existing beige? In some communities, you may still need approval. Architectural rules can require an application even when an owner intends to repaint in the existing color. Nothing says homeownership quite like asking permission to change nothing.

#5. Your front yard may require six shrubs. Not five.
One Arizona association's landscaping standards specify a minimum of one 24-inch-box tree, one 15-gallon tree, and six 5-gallon plants in the front yard. Somewhere, presumably, shrub number six is holding the entire streetscape together.

#6. There is an approved shade of brown
The same community requires certain walls to be painted Sherwin-Williams SW 9093 — Nearly Brown unless another color is approved. Not brown. Nearly Brown. Someone named that paint color, and somewhere else someone put it in the rules.

#7. The screen door may require committee approval
One association's architectural standards specifically say exterior screen doors must be approved by the architectural committee. You thought you were buying a screen door. You were beginning an application process.

#8. Rollerblading may be against the rules
One association's rules prohibit roller blades, skates, skateboards, motorized scooters and similar devices on association property. Kids, please take your recreation somewhere less recreational.

#9. Your garage sale may require permission
Some HOAs ban individual garage sales or limit them to designated community-wide events. So yes, you own the lamp. You just may need board approval to get rid of it.

#10. A basketball hoop can require a governance process
In Utah, a homeowner submitted plans, landscaping ideas, and even noise information for a basketball hoop. The committee deadlocked, the hoop was denied, and the dispute eventually reached a state advisory proceeding. Read Advisory Opinion 2026-09.

♓︎